MSOC 11-15
4
Messiah MESS (17-3-2, 7-0-1)
5
Winner Amherst AMH (10-4-6, 2-3-5)
Messiah MESS
(17-3-2, 7-0-1)
4
Final
5
Amherst AMH
(10-4-6, 2-3-5)
Winner
Score By Periods
Team 1 2 OT 1 F
Messiah MESS 1 3 0 4
Amherst AMH 0 4 1 5

Game Recap: Men's Soccer |

No. 19 Messiah Men’s Soccer Falls in Overtime Thriller at No. 8 Amherst

AMHERST, Mass. – On Sunday afternoon, the nineteenth-ranked Messiah University men's soccer fell in an overtime thriller to the eighth-ranked Mammoths of Amherst College, 5-4 in the Second Round of the NCAA Tournament. The Falcons got on the board first in the 18th minute with a goal from Sam Phillips by Owen Resch. Neither team added a goal in the remaining of the first half to keep the Falcons lead at 1-0 at the break. The Mammoths opened the second half strong with a pair of goals to take a 2-1 lead in the 54th minute. The Falcons tied the game just a minute later on the second goal of the game from Phillips. The Mammoths responded again with a pair of goals to take a 4-2 lead in the 65th minute. The Falcons continued to battle and cut the Mammoths lead to one with a goal from Grant Shreiner in the 71st minute.  The Falcons then tied the game in the 81st minute on a goal from Elijah Perry. The Falcons added one last chance in the 89th minute, but Amherst goalkeeper made a diving save to force overtime. The Mammoths scored the game-winner just 56 seconds into overtime to earn the 5-4 win.
 
First Half
The Mammoths looked to get on the board with an early chance in the fourth minute, but Killian O'Reilly made an early save to keep the game scoreless. The Falcons got their first chance in the 18th minute. Owen Resch sent a low cross across the box to Sam Phillips. Phillips then ripped a shot into the back of the goal to give the Falcons an early 1-0 lead. The Falcons continued on the attack and sent a shot on goal from Resch, but the Mammoths keeper made the save to keep the score at 1-0 in the 20th minute. Both teams went back-and-forth for the remainder of the first half to keep the Falcons lead at 1-0 at the break.
 
Second Half
The Mammoths opened the second half looking for the equalizing goal early. After they sent two chances on goal, the Mammoths broke through on the scoreboard in the 53rd minute with a goal. Just a little over a minute later, the Mammoths took the lead with another goal. The Falcons though responded with Sam Phillips' second goal of the game to tie the game at two. The high-scoring second half continued with Amherst scoring two goals to take a 4-2 lead in the 65th minute. The Falcons though would not go down without a fight. Grant Shreiner scored a goal that cut the Amherst lead to one in the 71st minute. The Falcons continued to battle, and Elijah Perry scored the tying goal in the 81st minute. The Falcons continued to control momentum and Perry sent two more shots on goal, but each shot was saved by the Mammoths' goalkeeper to keep the game tied at four headed into overtime.
 
Overtime
The Mammoths scored the game-winner 56 seconds into overtime to earn the 5-4 win, and advance to the Sweet Sixteen.
 
Stats
Sam Phillips led the Falcons with two goals. Elijah Perry and Grant Shreiner each scored a goal. Owen Resch added an assist. The Falcons totaled 14 shots with seven shots on goal. The Mammoths tallied 20 shots with nine shots on goal. Amherst earned five corner kicks to Messiah's four. Killian O'Reilly started in goal for the Falcons and made three saves.
 
Season Recap
The Falcons cap off the 2026 season with a 17-3-2 overall record. The Falcons earned an at-large bid to the NCAA Tournament after falling in the MAC Commonwealth Championship game. The Falcons advanced to the NCAA Tournament Second Round for the ninth-straight season.